Governments in West Africa are taking action to stop the import of fuel with dangerously high levels of sulfur and other toxins. Much of the so-called “dirty diesel” originates in Europe, according to a report published by Public Eye, a Swiss NGO, last year.
The report exposed what Public Eye calls the “illegitimate business” of European oil companies and commodities traders selling low quality fuel to Africa. While European standards prohibit the use of diesel with a sulphur content higher than 10 parts per million (ppm), diesel with as much as 3 000 ppm is regularly exported to Africa.
From July 1, diesel being sold at the pumps in Ghana and Nigeria will have to meet a maximum 50 ppm standard.
“We’re very happy to see this change in policy,” Public Eye’s Oliver Classen told DW. “We are still hoping that other West African countries will follow suit, such as the Ivory Coast, Benin, Togo or Mali.”
Health risks of dirty diesel
During an investigation spanning three years, Public Eye tested the fuel for sale at gas stations in eight African countries, five of which were in West Africa. They found that more than two thirds of the samples taken had a sulfur level 150 times the European limit.
Africa’s cities are growing quickly. Lagos, Nigeria’s largest city, has a population of 21 million, and estimates suggest this number could almost double by the year 2050. Bigger cities mean a much greater risk from air pollution. While rapid urbanisation and the poor quality of the largely second-hand car fleet in the region are partly responsible for the high levels of air pollution, low quality diesel also has a significant impact.
Nigeria’s largest city, Lagos, already has a population of 21-million
Fuel pollutants have been linked to the development of asthma, lung cancer and cardiovascular diseases. The Public Eye report claimed that switching to low sulphur fuel in Africa, as well as introducing cars with modern emissions control technologies, could prevent 25 000 premature deaths in 2030 and 100 000 in 2050.
Classen explains that Public Eye has been driving a “two-fold campaign” in order to force change in the fuel industry.
“Our partner organisations in West Africa made sure that this strong message from the people who are suffering from these sulfurous emissions on the ground is heard by their governments,” he says. “In Switzerland we put pressure on the companies that take advantage of these double standards - shamelessly, ruthlessly, systematically.”
The report focuses on Swiss trading companies that use a process known as “blending” to combine low and high specification fuel, creating a mixture that complies with weak African regulations. As the report explains, “the closer to the specification boundary the product lies, the larger the potential margin for the trader.”
The harmful effects of diesel have been well publicised in Europe in recent years
This sub-standard product, known in the industry as “African Quality,” could not be sold in Europe, but it is not illegal for it to be sold elsewhere. The blending process - which takes place either in European ports or en route to Africa, via a “ship-to-ship” transfer - complicates the matter, because fuel from various suppliers can be mixed into one product.
According to Public Eye, Swiss companies also own, or are major stakeholders in companies that own, a great deal of the “downstream” infrastructure used for blending, transporting and distributing fuel - such as ships, storage tanks, petrol stations and pipelines.
Despite having significant oil reserves, West Africa lacks sufficient refinery resource to process its own higher quality oil and has therefore welcomed cheaper imports from abroad.
Following the report, governments in five West African countries were quick to pledge an overhaul of fuel regulations. Ghana and Nigeria are the first to follow through on this promise. But what about the commodities traders in Europe?
“They actually didn’t respond at all,” Classen says. “We brought up a petition here in Switzerland, and 20 000 people signed that petition asking those commodities giants to stop selling dirty diesel to Africa. But nothing happened. Zero.”
The two main commodities companies implicated in the report were Trafigura and Vitol. Both told DW that, while they accepted that the problem of high sulfur fuel needed to be dealt with, the onus was on the governments in Africa to ensure the quality of diesel being sold at the pumps.
Vitol added that, under current regulations, European companies cannot be certain that what they supply to importers from a certain country will then be sold in that country. “If Vitol, or any other supplier, were to supply EU-specification (at a financial loss) to an importer, there is nothing to stop the importer from reselling the cargo, at a profit, and sourcing a cargo with a cheaper specification for local use.”
Pressure on the middle men
Around 50% of the European oil that ends up in West Africa flows through the ports of Antwerp, Rotterdam and Amsterdam, known as the ARA region. Public Eye called on these “export hubs” to ban the export of fuel that does not meet European standards.
“There’s a huge public debate going on in the Netherlands and Belgium,” Classen explains. “There have been parliamentary motions and a whole lot of media coverage on the issue, and there’s pressure on their governments there. We are hoping to see some change of mind which would put Swiss commodity traders under sever pressure to change their business practices.”
In response to concerns about tougher regulations pushing up fuel prices, Public Eye points out that five East African countries adopted low sulfur fuels in January 2015 “with no impact on prices at the pump.”
Ghana has significant oil reserves but only one refinery, the state-owned Tema facility
Mahamudu Bawumia, the Vice President of Ghana, said that the introduction of the new regulations would see Ghana “moving to be at the same level as the western countries or the East African countries.”
He added that the changes “will reduce respiratory diseases triggered by fuel toxins with higher sulphur content.”
Nigeria has also announced plans for all domestically produced fuel to meet the 50 ppm standards by 2020. At a meeting of African fuel producers in February, Ndu Ughamadu, the spokesperson for the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation, said that the installation of equipment to cut sulphur emissions was already underway or planned at three of Nigeria’s four refineries.